Hotdog, Wiener, Frankfurter - call it what you want, but according to some culinary experts it doesn't call it a sandwich.
Does God exist?Are we alone in the universe?A few drinks at a party.And in the past decade, another disputed thought has continued to investigate the Spirit at night, what that didmemesAnd claims Reddit in the longest range: is a hot dog a sandwich?
To be honest (furter) it is just one of the many Vienna-related questions that swallow the mind.Hot dog rolls in a packageWhen hot dogs are sold in packages of ten.ENDNU is more basic base "What are hot dogs made of?"
For the purpose of this article we skip other debates andMadfakta TriviaTo stay hyperfoke about whether the hot dog belongs in the same category as BLTs, clubs, Pastrami-Sandwich and Reubens.We grilled experts from both sides of the grocer to see if we could reach a consensus about the status of the stadium.: a bite - er, bit - of the story.
On this page
Who invented the hot dog?
Like "Is a hot dog a sandwich?"Births of many preferred resourcesThis study is strongly disputed according to the National Hot Dog and Sausage Council (NHDSC).birthdayI 1987.
Foodies from Vienna, Austria, claim that they are the originators of the hot dog and use the fact that we call it a Vienna as their evidence.
Others claim that a popular sausage called a dach dog ("small dog") was invented by butcher Johann Georggehner in the late 1600s in Coburg, Germany.Generations of immigrants butchers from a number of European countries.
Why is it called a hot dog?
The disputed disputed is also what Wiener was called a hot dog over the years.
The word "hotdog" began to appear in college magazines in the 1890s.
But there is another story about how Terneper became - it is nicer to tell, although it was probably composed in that story.Is red -hot!New York JournalCartoonist, Tad Dorgan, witnessed the stage and drew a cartoon with beamed sausages in sandwiches.
A goat in the validity of this story of origin: according to NHDSC, historians have not been able to find the cartoon.
What is a sandwich?
Two important definitions have probably activated "Is a hot dog a sandwich?"Conversation as "a slice of bread covered with food."(The other bit helps to understand open sandwich.)
Ons. Department of Agriculture (USDA) describes a sandwich as "two slices of bread or the upper and lower parts of a sliced sandwich that encloses meat or poultry."They refer back to the formulation of USDA.
Why is a hot dogtechnicallyIn sandwich?
According to the official definition, a hot dog is a sandwich.This help of individual interpretations of USDA's definitions says rich hope, Chief Marketing Officer at Sandwich Chain Jersey Mike's: "There are many ways to make sandwiches, so that it can certainly be hot dogs."
Because a hot dog is flanked by bread and lubricated with herbs such asketchupAnd mustard that sounds a lot like a sandwich, it's easy to see why people in this camp have a leg for (hot dog) to get up.American cheeseSingles for sandwiches and someBest Hot DogsOn the Markt - employees enjoy the opportunity to regularly discuss whether a hot dog is a sandwich, according to senior brand manager Gina Gancheva.
"We have employees on both sides," she says.Dog is not a sandwich. "
She notes that the limited terminology of USDA is problematic and excludes large shards of the sandwich family, includingPeanut butter and jelly"If we pass the USDA, the beloved grilled cheese would not be eligible," she says.
Why is a hot dog notRealIn sandwich?
While most experts hesitated to lay their feet on one side of the debate, those who were in favor of leaving the sandwich category are much firmer.
"A hot dog is his own unique thing, a cylindrically formed protein that is in a sandwich, and no sandwich" Hotdog is definitely earned by his own category, just like a hamburger deserves his own. "
Joey Chestnut, the 14-way winner of the aforementioned competition, went to Twitter in 2017 to confirm that he is not tolerating itGrove reality through competitive foodFor just every ole '', it's #national hot dogday. "
In view of the fact that Americans spent more than $ 7.5 billion in American markets on dogs and sausages in 2021, Eric Mittenthal, president of the NHDSC (the best dog of Hotdogs) claims that Franks from Generic Sandwich classification has grown."The importance of it can be limited by forcing it to a larger sandwich category, but that time has passed."
It's a matter of bread
Mittenthal also claims that as a sandwich to qualify, there must be a bread component."It is called a hot dog when it is on a sandwich. It is called a hot dog if it is not," he says.Dog;That's why it's not a sandwich. "
It's a matter of story
McCann points out that it is a matter of semantics., why wouldn't they have called the hot dog a sandwich if he was invented 100 years later if it was a sandwich?"
It's a matter of language
Not that you think this is a kind of anti-sandwich alliance on the east coast, we were looking for Richard Pink, the co-owner of Pink's Hot Dogs, to get his tag.Hans Restaurant in Frankfurter-Focus is a milestone in Los Angeles since his parents started the joint in 1939. Incidentally, the inhabitants of the city consume more hot dogs than anyone else in the US and huge £ 30 million a year!He agrees that it is a matter of accepted linguistics.
"In ordinary language and practice, at least in America, if you asked people to tell you what a hot dog is, they would not describe a sandwich. And if you asked them to define a sandwich, no one would say:" ATubular piece of meat that fits in a bowl, "says Pink."hamburgers.'"
The verdict
After we have spoken with experts, we are not closer to explaining that this discourse has been resolved.tortilla.)
For every professional who voted no, someone else with hot dog skin in the game on the other side of the philosophical spectrum, just like Oscar Mayer in 2018. The company posted on social media that hot dogs is sandwich, then it was opened hotline for no-Seggers to try to convince them differently.
Even ordinary Jees and Janes remain warm distributed.A little more than half of all respondents they don't think belong to dogs in the sandwich category.
He is doubtful that the nation will even stop rebuilding whether a hot dog is a sandwich or not.Years and shows no signs of release. "
Our suggestions: forget the definition and just enjoy the bowl.ketchupOr mustard, top with tasty or love chili, peppers and onions, bacon or sauerkraut.French friesFor one of the most American meals of all time.
Then look at what placeBest hot dog in every state.
Sources:
- Rich Hope, Chief Marketing Officer I Sandwich ChainJersey Mike's
- Gina Gancheva, senior brand manager atImpose
- Phil McCann, vice -president van marketing opNathan is famous
- Eric Mittenthal, president vanNational hot dog a worstaad
- Richard Pink, co -owner ofPink's Hotdogs
- National hot dog a worstaad: "Hotdogschiedis"
- US Department of Agriculture: "Mad Standards and Labeling Policy Book"
- @Joeyjaws: "Joey Chestnut på Twitter"
- @Oscarmayer: "Oscar Mayer op Twitter"
- National hot dog a worstaad: "Americans solve the hardest hot dog tunes"
